Written
by DAVID KEYES
If Roman Polanski were not the same man who directed "Chinatown"
and "Rosemary's Baby," he might never have been
equipped enough to tell a story as difficult and poignant
as that of "The Pianist." It's easy to pretend
that a narrative of this emotional caliber simply requires
a filmmaker with a distinctive knowledge of cinema, but
the demand goes far beyond that; compassion and association
are prerequisites as well. Not surprisingly, Polanski's
greatest films explore parallel subjectsvictimization,
claustrophobia, and an underlying dogged hope that keeps
the human spirit elevated to survivaland having mastered
the themes before most modern directors even knew how to
use a camera, he sort of becomes fated into the position,
as if every significant product in his career has merely
been a prelude to him forging this one. The fact that the
story itself correlates with most of what went on in his
own early life doesn't hurt matters, either.
"The Pianist" is about Wladyslaw Szpilman, a
master and poet of the piano, who also happens to be a Polish
Jew living in the clouded atmosphere of World War II. The
movie opens in 1939 in Warsaw, as the musician is serenading
his listeners on radio with Chopin just as the Germans invade
the area and begin unleashing their all-too-familiar fury
against the Jewish population. Signs shamelessly claiming
that "No Jews are allowed" hang from the windows
of local businesses. Nazi soldiers even enforce law that
forbids them from walking on sidewalk pavements. But Wladyslaw
and the members of his close-knit family are not too fearful
of what the future will bringafter all, they have
wealth, social status... and hope stemming from the early
promises of radio announcers, who inform their fearful ears
that the British and French have just declared war on the
Germans.
But the status of the Jewish population in Warsaw quickly
dwindles. Just when their society begins to anticipate nothing
worse, the Nazis take their campaign to drastic measures
by creating a "Jewish district" in the middle
of townthat is, a ghetto in which all Jews are separated
from other Polish residents, a factor which is further stressed
by a high brick wall built to surround the area and keep
them enclosed (one devastating scene in which we discover
a hole at the bottom of the wall shows how any Jewish resistance
is painfully answered). The violence and torture escalates;
the Szpilman family begins to lose its grasp on faith; and
Wladyslaw realizes that only a short amount of time could
be separating he and his family for almost-certain death
at the hands of their enemies. Seeking endlessly for ways
to stay in the area as rumors begin breaching about the
Polish being shipped off to concentration camps, he even
gets every member of his family granted a certificate of
employment to work in the ghetto for the remaining Nazi
soldiers, although when the Germans put their own two-cents
into the scenario, only Wladyslaw himself actually gets
to stay behind. And even then, he doesn't get to keep his
access to a piano.
The lead role is filled rather amazingly by Adrian Brody,
who has come a long way since his breakout performance as
a Latin punk rocker in "Summer of Sam." The calmness
and subtlety of his exertion, exercised even during the
scenes that require him to simply daydream of playing his
favorite musical instrument, is some of the most convincing
seen on screen this last year. He doesn't just play the
material, but lives and breathes it with every ounce of
conviction he has, even when his character undergoes major
physical and emotional transformations during the script's
six-year time period. Most actors might have played a role
like this straight in the first half and then gone overboard
with the substantial material of the last. But Brody doesn't
make that mistake here; he seems to understand (and embody)
the rapid decline of his persona, but doesn't feel obligated
to underplay or overreact in the role, either.
For Polanski, a man who has won great admiration even for
his less-than-perfect screen efforts (his most recent was
"The Ninth Gate"), the film represents a new peak
in his ever-fascinating body of work. It is a harshbut
incredibly movingpiece of filmmaking, a work of genuine
depth and sensibility that never loses its focus or compromises
its integrity. The movie, of course, is based on a factual
account from the legendary pianist himself, but perhaps
it represents a memory of the director's than anything else.
During his early years, Polanski, who lived in Poland when
the Germans invaded, lost his mother to a concentration
camp and was separated from his father, left to fend for
himself in his own treacherous ghettos in hopes that the
Nazis wouldn't take their cruel shooting habits to the limit
and end his young and innocent life. We imagine that those
years are difficult for anyone to relive, and though the
filmmaker has hinted at those conflicts over the years with
his most brilliant cinematic works, none of it quite compares
to the sheer power of watching his "The Pianist"
unfold on screen, which plays primarily like it is a fresh
memory from his tormented mind. To be expected, the movie
is rather violent and gory in some patches, but as Polanski
himself once said, "You have to show violence the way
it is. If you don't show it realistically, then that's immoral
and harmful."
In the end, the mark of any great director is perseverance
through the shadows, and Polanski's success with "The
Pianist" keeps him in company with the likes of Martin
Scorcese and Steven Spielberg as one of our most gifted
living movie directors. And like the most uplifting motion
pictures of our time, this isn't a movie formulated on facades
or manipulations, but realistic intentions that ultimately
expose the spirit and endurance of the human soul. To call
the result one of the year's most impressive cinematic compositions
would not completely do it justice.