Written
by DAVID KEYES
There is immediate difficulty for people, like me, who
go into "Stuart Little 2" without having seen
so much as a frame of the first film (or for that matter,
without having read a single line from the famous children's
book by E.B. White, who also created "Charlotte's Web").
How do you approach the experience? What is required of
those of us who have no foreknowledge whatsoever about the
already-established subject matter we are confronted with?
And furthermore, are we in an unfair position to judge a
film on its merits when the foundation for the plot was
anchored in an earlier movie that we have yet to see?
I encourage readers and friends who immerse themselves
in these kinds of experiences to simply keep open minds
when going into the theater, but that sometimes isn't enough.
The definite test in these situations, as it is with any
kind of sequel, is to examine the basic structure: is the
movie and its material truly of itself, or does it heavily
depend on what has already been established? Not all motion
pictures fall under the same answer, and that's okay; some
require a heavy reference to the past (such as the films
of "Star Wars") while others can start from scratch
and forget about everything that happened beforehand ("Grease
2," for instance).
"Stuart Little 2" falls somewhere in between
both categories, and on that basis has its highs and lows
in terms of foundation. But once we're acquainted with the
fundamentals, the movie begins to build a charming and observant
little vehicle of childhood entertainment that melts away
all the reservations we take into the theater with us. No,
the movie doesn't demand that you view the original "Stuart
Little" outing in order to understand everything going
on, and though a few of the past references tend to pass
quickly over some heads, it's never too obvious to prevent
us from having a decent time.
The picture is a silly but amusing package of innocence,
fantasy, adventure and color, stirred together as if it
were replicating the rich imaginations that kids take to
the movie theater. As it opens, we're invited into the household
of the Littles, a cheery and "normal" family that
consists of a mother, a father, a little boy, an infant,
a cat, and.... A talking mouse, who the others consider
an integral part of the family structure. His name is Stuart
(Michael J. Fox), and aside from his small proportion, he
lives a very normal and accepted life amongst his friends
and relatives. No one seems to acknowledge the fact that
he is just four inches high in length, but there is a hint
of that quality bubbling beneath the conflict of the story,
which is that Stuart's size severely undermines his potential
for friendship and respect. When he joins his brother's
soccer team, everyone is enthused by the addition (with
the exception of the mother, Eleanor, played by Geena Davis).
But when the chips are down, Stuart is forced to sit on
the sidelines and watch his other teammates play; apparently
cleats and little mice don't mesh very well on the playing
field.
One day during a routine drive from school to home, Stuart
meets an injured female bird named Margalo (Melanie Griffith),
who crashes into his passenger seat after trying to escape
a foreboding falcon (James Woods) in the skies above. Stuart
takes an instant liking to this small creature, the first,
we gather, that Stuart has met and communicated with during
his entire life with the Littles. Reluctantly, Margalo accepts
an offer to recuperate at his residence, but later, seemingly
without a trace, she disappears from his life altogether.
This encourages our heroic rodent to set out on a journey
in the big city to find and rescue his new best friend,
whom Stuart suspects has finally been napped by the same
old falcon.
The key to this very simple plot structure lies in laughs,
and "Stuart Little 2" has a surprisingly strong
sense of humor to convey its jokes. Not all of it is physical
comedy, either; in fact, the dialogue is almost witty and
cute enough to deserve the steep ticket price. The majority
of the best quips and one-liners are delivered via Nathan
Lane, who voices Snowball, a Persian family cat whose attitude
towards Stuart is a lot more tame than we'd expect from
a ferocious-looking feline. When he is tricked into helping
Stuart on his search in the big city for Margalo, Snowball
makes his displeasure known quite well. Later, when he and
the mouse are warned about the harsh reputation of the falcon
they are seeking out, the four-legged furball announces,
"Guess what? I no longer need a litter box."
The live action cast exists merely as it deserves to: it's
a generic platform to usher us into the world of these tiny
but charming little creatures. There are a few standout
moments, though, when Geena Davis is the target of our attention;
her possessive attitude and simplistic structure are ideal
qualities of a mother in these types of movies, and yet
not too plastic to feel like they've been pulled away from
a 1950s sitcom parent. She's a sweet and gentle woman, worried
intensely about the well-being of the smallest family member
when other people don't seem to notice how different he
is from everyone.
Naturally, the movie still has its share of reservations
as well. The concept of talking mice and birds coexisting
with the human race, for instance, is a somewhat implausible
one, especially in movies that tend to forget that there
are obvious differences between them. Moreover, there are
points when the movie feels overly simplistic and stripped
down, as if the filmmakers are expecting their young audience
to be near brain-dead. But "Stuart Little 2" doesn't
dwell too much on these failures, and in fact does a very
decent job of trying to work around most of its shortcomings.
The movie isn't grand or spectacular by any means, but given
the climate of movies for children right now, it sure beats
the likes of "Scooby-Doo."