Written
by DAVID KEYES
The plethora of jokes that find their way into the bowels
of "Stealing Harvard" occupy the screen like early
drafts of wisecracks featured in "There's Something
About Mary" and "American Pie," tossing around
the essence of bad taste without ever actually getting to
a punch line. You are no doubt familiar with the concept
of gross-out comedy and all its contingencies, but do you
truly know the difference between that which is successful
and that which is not? The audience of a recent promotional
screening for the film certainly didn't, as they zealously
chuckled through the 84-minute endeavor like undernourished
preteens who hadn't seen a good comedy in years. Considering
the frightening consistency of their laughs, it wouldn't
surprise me in the least if that were true.
When it comes to being just plain unpleasant, "Stealing
Harvard" seems to hit every right note. The movie is
tired, childish, obvious and pathetic down to the most minute
details, not even amusing enough to at least stimulate our
negative response beyond dozing off. There is a moment early
in the picture when the lead character breaks into a rich
man's home, is caught, and then forced to dress like a woman
so that the homeowner can spoon with him. What makes the
joke painful to sit through is not the fact that it's completely
stiff and uninspired, but the fact that it repeats itself
not once but twice before the movie takes us to its closing
credits. The screenplay by Martin Hynes and Peter Tolan
doesn't even deserved to be acknowledged as a script; it's
more like a series of disorganized cliff notes which are
meant to tease better jokes in better movies without actually
revealing all the necessary details.
The idiot plot revolves around John Plummer (Jason Lee),
a young ambitious guy who is about to marry the love of
his life, Elaine (Leslie Mann) and settle down to have a
family with her. Elaine makes the announcement early on
that their joint bank account has reached a balance beyond
30K, which will allow them to put a down payment on a dream
home for them to live in. Unfortunately, the news comes
just at the time when John's niece Noreen is accepted into
Harvard University, and the hardworking guy is reminded
by his trailer trash sister that he promised to pay for
the tuition years before. As luck would have it, the total
remaining to be paid for her education rounds out to around
30K as well. The conflict: does John squash his fiancee's
dreams of happiness by giving Noreen the money in his account?
Or does he go through with buying a house and break his
promise to one of his only sane family members?
As usually is the case with these types of comedies, the
movie has an alternative answer. In "Stealing Harvard,"
that option comes in the form of Tom Green, Hollywood's
latest one-trick pony, who plays John's obnoxious friend
Duff. The wacko landscaper is approached by Plummer with
this distressing news, but Duff has a lot of ideas. Actually,
he has a lot of illegal ideas, but that's not the point.
John is of course very hesitant about following through
with his friend's lurid suggestions, but seeing the only
other way out of his situation is to hurt one person he
loves, he realizes rather quickly that he has no other choice.
This gives the movie permission to throw him into all sorts
of unlikely but dangerous situations, including a botched
liquor store robbery, an ambiguous pact with the local mobster,
and even a halfhearted attempt to cash in on miners who
want easy access to alcohol and cigarettes. And the movie
doesn't even bother to resolve its conflict with any of
these elaborate gimmicks; the conclusion actually stems
from a suggestion made early on by one of the characters,
which everyone ignores until they've tried everything else,
and failed at it.
The script's biggest error is that it bites off a lot more
than it can chew; the energy and ambition are there, but
the content doesn't resemble anything close to what is possible
with the concept. Further fuel is added to the fire when
Tom Green, a former host of a pre-"Jackass" MTV
variety show, makes his long-dreaded appearance in the film
but barely comes off as a lite version of his former annoying
self. Green isn't exactly the kind of person who you'd want
to pass on the street, nor is he the kind of person you'd
want to see often on the movie screen (see "Freddy
Got Fingered" for a better understanding). But no matter
what his faults as an entertainer are, he always has one
constant: his level of zany energy is unmatched, even by
today's standards. That factor alone makes him an awkward
cast for a movie as dry and poor as this one; watching him
try to unleash every ounce of his own annoying wackiness
is like seeing the Energizer bunny unleash all its battery
power on the top of some cold and deserted mountain slope.
In both cases, it's better to spend your money watching
something a little more productive... and perhaps something
a little more amusing.
Author's Note: Although "Stealing
Harvard" has been equipped with a PG-13 rating, a lot
of its material could and should be considered unsuitable
for consumption by those in that age range.