Written
by DAVID KEYES
The service of photographs in "One Hour Photo"
is as fundamental to the premise as the red roses in Sam
Mendes' "American Beauty," in which ordinary items
that pass though our daily lives without much importance
take on an identity of their own when they fall into the
hands of someone outside of the norm. In writer/director
Mark Romanek's feature film about a reclusive and mysterious
anti-hero who works a retail chain's photo processing division
like it were a lost art form, seemingly innocent little
snapshots of everyday events are rescued from the clutches
of passive American photographers and treated like rare
precious gems, each signifying a moment in one's life that
was crucial enough to garner a camera's focus. Why do people
not see the beauty of each and every frame on a negative
strip? Why do they place their development in the hands
of complete strangers who care nothing about their content?
Such questions are the everyday musings of Sy Parrish, a
middle-aged nobody whose obsession with the printed images
slowly begins to blur the lines separating lucidity from
alienation. To him, pictures aren't simply forgotten treasures
or abused artifacts, either; in fact, photos themselves
become his only link to any feasible reality, even if the
reality itself turns out to be somewhat disturbing.
"One Hour Photo" is pitched to the viewer with
one of the most inaccurate marketing curves seen in ages,
unfortunately; it's not a suspense vehicle as ads would
suggest, but rather a sad, somber and deeply thought-provoking
little film where isolation tears holes open in the soul
of someone who may, or may not, be a very wise and respectable
man beneath the quiet public facade. The movie is brilliantly
written and directed down to the last frame, inarguably
not without its share of creepy moments but so much more
intimate than just a standard suspense drama.
The Parrish character that seizes direct focus of the viewer
is played brilliantly by Robin Williams, an actor who, after
several recent failures in comedy, stumbled on a new niche
of creativity with a role in the thriller "Insomnia"
earlier this year. Whereas that performance had a very unnerving
edge to it, though, the work here doesn't depend primarily
on its creepiness factor to get ahead. Minus a few scenes
in which the persona is driven to sadistic actions, furthermore,
the role is actually more dramatic than anything else, subdued
and suggestive down to the last page of the script without
demanding the audience to expect anything more or less.
In the story, Parrish is the longtime employee of a small
photo processing division inside the local retail center,
a vast bargain shop where everyone in town seems to wind
up at one point in their daily routines. In all his years
of experience, Sy has come to recognize most of his customers
by name, particularly the members of the Yorkin household,
who embody all the quality traits of the ideal American
family through the portraits they develop: Nina (Connie
Nielsen), a beautiful young mother, Will (Michael Vartan),
a hardworking father, and Jake (Dylan Smith), a curious
young boy with a soft spot for people who, like Sy, don't
seem to have any friends. To them, Mr. Parrish is simply
that nice old guy who develops all of their pictures, sometimes
giving them larger prints than what they requested, but
beneath the surface he is a lonely and desperate man in
search of some kind of acceptance. His indigence, needless
to say, is hardly what can be considered healthy, and when
we're taken to his spruce little apartment early on in the
picture, alarm ensues when we see one of his walls decorated
by duplicate copies of all the Yorkin photos developed over
the years, each hung almost too precise for words.
The movie wrestles with a lot of these unsettling images
during the surge of its brief 98-minute running time, but
it doesn't want to pass off as a thriller or anything remotely
similar to one. "One Hour Photo" is at the core
a character study, and a distinctive one at that, which
builds itself through irony and tension but never actually
goes through the gate of horror like most other movies would.
Romanek's film, furthermore, wields a very bleached and
mundane style to emphasize the empty life that Parrish leads
both in and out of the workplace, in which sets have the
simplistic charisma of a childlike mind, and the cinematography,
especially during Sy's informative photo development commentaries,
never ceases to suck the characters into the script's vacuum
of uncertainty. But these aren't negative qualities in the
least; if anything, washed out tone employed by the movie's
texture is rather refreshing, especially in a time when
even the most dynamic films tend to over-dramatize their
exteriors.
Romanek, as most viewers probably know, is widely known
for his innovative additions to the music video medium (he
even worked with Madonna and Michael Jackson), and though
the man is credited with another major motion picture before
those small-screen endeavors, he hasn't truly been recognized
for his work on a wide scale. This is the movie that will
catapult him into the circle of Hollywood's most gifted
filmmakers, and in a time when the cinema is starting to
wind down and prepare for the onslaught of would-be Oscar
hopefuls, it is also one of the most surprisingly brilliant.