Rating
-
Drama (US); 1999;
Rated R; 162 Minutes
Cast
Al Pacino: Tony D'Amato
Dennis Quaid: Jack "Cap" Rooney
James Woods: Dr. Harvey Mandrake
Ann-Margret: Margaret Pagniacci
Todd Bacile: Sideline Sound Tech
Bill Bellamy: Jimmy Sanderson #88
Elizabeth Berkley: Mandy
Produced by Dan Halsted,
Lauren Shuler Donner, Oliver Stone and Clayton Townsend;
Directed by Oliver Stone; Screenwritten by John
Logan and Oliver Stone; based on the novel by Pat
Toomay
Review Uploaded
12/31/99 |
Written
by DAVID KEYES Any
Given Sunday" chooses football as its sport backbone, and
maybe rightfully so, because much like the game it chooses
to dramatize, players bend or break rules and don't seem
to care, just as long as they finish ahead of the others.
The fact alone that that the deafening material even tries
to play as a drama inflames me; here is a movie of laughably
bad proportions, shot with extensive graininess, directed
at an unforgivably slow pace, and glorified by a sport that
may very well be duller than the O.J. Simpson trial. Oh,
and there's even a marvelous cast behind the production,
adding insult to injury to our already-stupefied minds.
It's bad enough that the movie is loud and obnoxious; must
it also waste hordes of talent on a script that manages
to use every sport cliché known in the movies?
Boy
is this thing horrible; "Any Given Sunday" is a lame, irritating,
stupid and relentless endeavor with absolutely no one we
can care about, much less find amusing. It tells of Pro
football's behind-the-scenes glamour, in which the team
of Miami Sharks is cheered on by fans on field, but badgered
by coaches and managers inside locker rooms, who scream
at and irritate each other like members of the two households
in "American Beauty." But whereas those arguments had points,
the characters in this wallowing mess get agitated for all
the wrong reasons--petty arguments, like one that goes on
between the coach (Al Pacino) and the owner (Cameron Diaz),
grow tired and stale practically in the first scene they
are introduced. A more interesting movie would have chosen
either the players or those behind-the-scene people to focus
on, but the movie cannot even make up its mind what direction
to go in, and instead threads them (conflicts on one side
interfere with those on the other on more than one occasion).
Which
brings us to the implausible imagery. The cinematographer's
style of on-field action, shot with hand-held cameras and
deafening pounds in the soundtrack, creates some of the
most chaotic photography seen in a film all year. It's impossible
to clearly understand what's going on when players prepare
to make their move, the shot changes to a worse angle, and
then returns to the previous location about two seconds
too late to see the actions clearly. In most respects, the
picture may very well be the cinematic equivalent of taking
a video camera and letting big football players toss it
around more than their inflated tool. Furthermore, the players
who crash into each other on field grunt, scream, yell,
and shout out every cuss word known to mankind, suggesting
that the scripted dialogue has been written with a lack
of intelligence and innovation; the movie may very well
be the first to match "South Park: Bigger, Longer & Uncut"
in profanity.
Stone's
story tells of a fictional Miami team named the Dolphins,
who can hopefully become the year's champions--that is,
if they can ditch their middle-aged quarterback (Dennis
Quaid) for a newly-discovered football star (Jaime Foxx).
Worrying more about winning than honoring an old hero, however,
the movie discards that story for the source of the football
game's obsessive party; in this case, we're referring to
Al Pacino as the Miami Sharks coach. His life has been devoted
to the game, and, in order for his team to reach their goals,
he has to push them hard enough (which isn't easy, since
the season is already off to a bad start). Multiple subplots
erupt from this underlying premise; football players' wives
become alcoholics, fights between players break out, and
tensions between coaches and owners escalate. Then there's
a big football game towards the end, which reaches into
the sports film knapsack and pulls out all the predictable
twists necessary to wrap up the production with that sappy,
routine studio ending. At least in those movies, the cinematography
was able to sustain a decent demonstration of a sports game.
Is
there any indication here that director Oliver Stone wanted
another Oscar rival on his hands with this project? The
fact that it is being released in the midst of several Academy
Award contenders is reason enough; his use of dramatic and
photographic overkill are so frustrating that, even if the
film had a distinct script, there would be no way to tell
exactly, or care, what was going on. But most of his past
directorial efforts work (his "Natural Born Killers," for
instance, had just the right tone to take us into the heads
of two media-glorified murderers); this type of stuff is
so pretentious and overdone that not even a fan of football
can find much to appreciate. Stone is a solid director and
will undoubtedly make greater movies in the future; this
time, someone should have pulled him from the lineup.
©
1999, David Keyes, Cinemaphile.org.
Please e-mail the author here
if the above review contains any spelling or grammar mistakes. |